# Poppy 1.0 vs 6 Agent Protocols (2026)

> Sierra released Poppy 1.0 on November 13, 2026, and Shopify switched it on for every store. Here is how it compares with UCP, PACT, Visa TAP, Mastercard Agent Pay, ACP and MCP.

By Arthur R. · Published 2026-11-15 · Updated 2026-11-15 · 9 min read · https://innvesti.com/reports/poppy-1-0-launch-agent-protocols-compared-2026/

## Quick answer

Poppy 1.0, released by Sierra on November 13, 2026, is a front-door protocol: it covers how a personal AI agent identifies itself to a business and what the customer has allowed it to do, not how it checks out. It sits beside shopping protocols such as UCP and ACP and identity schemes such as Visa TAP, and its closest direct rival is Decagon and Instinct's PACT.

## Key takeaways

- Sierra released Poppy 1.0 on November 13, 2026; every Shopify store now publishes a Poppy file automatically, and Meta's Muse checks for Poppy first on every site it visits.
- Poppy and UCP do different jobs. Per Sierra, UCP handles shopping (finding products, filling a cart, checkout) while Poppy handles what comes before: the agent arriving, identifying itself and learning what it may do.
- The 1.0 label is a launch name. The specification itself still says "draft 1.0" and permits changes that are not backward compatible, and payments are not part of the first version.
- PACT, from Decagon and Instinct, is the closest rival: it also separates who the agent is from what the customer lets it do, but builds on A2A and OAuth 2.0 and was published on October 6, 2026, the same day Poppy was announced.
- Visa's Trusted Agent Protocol and Mastercard Agent Pay answer a narrower question, whether an agent is a registered, trusted one, using signed HTTP requests under Cloudflare's Web Bot Auth scheme.

## Key figures

- **Nov 13, 2026** — Poppy 1.0 release date (Sierra)
- **100+** — Design partners Sierra reports for Poppy, 60 of them new for 1.0 (Sierra)
- **Oct 6, 2026** — Date Poppy was announced by Sierra and Meta, and PACT was open-sourced by Decagon

## Ranked

1. **Poppy (Personal Agent Protocol)** — Best for businesses that want to say who may bring an agent in the front door. https://sierra.ai/blog/releasing-poppy
2. **Universal Commerce Protocol (UCP)** — Best for the shopping itself, from discovery to checkout. https://www.shopify.com/ucp
3. **PACT (Personal Agent Consent & Trust Protocol)** — Closest rival; best for teams already built on A2A and OAuth. https://decagon.ai/blog/introducing-the-personal-agent-consent-trust-protocol-pact
4. **Visa Trusted Agent Protocol (with Web Bot Auth)** — Best for proving an agent is registered and trusted at the edge. https://blog.cloudflare.com/secure-agentic-commerce/
5. **Mastercard Agent Pay** — Best for card-network-grade controls on agent payments. https://www.mastercard.com/us/en/news-and-trends/press/2026/september/new-trust-and-intelligence-services.html
6. **Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP)** — Best for in-agent checkout with Stripe as the payment layer. https://stripe.com/blog/developing-an-open-standard-for-agentic-commerce
7. **Model Context Protocol (MCP)** — Best as the tool-calling channel that other protocols ride on. https://modelcontextprotocol.io/

## Comparison

| Protocol | Main job | Backers | Covers customer consent? | Status (Nov 15, 2026) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Poppy | Agent arrival, identity and scoped access | Sierra, Meta; Shopify co-authored commerce extension | Yes, via OAuth sign-in and scoped session tokens | 1.0 released Nov 13; spec text still "draft 1.0" |
| UCP | Shopping: discovery, cart, checkout, orders | Shopify, Google; Etsy, Wayfair, Target, Walmart | Not as its main job | Live; used by Shopify for carts and checkout |
| PACT | Agent identity plus customer delegation | Decagon, Instinct | Yes, via OAuth device flow and delegation token | Published Oct 6, 2026 |
| Visa TAP / Web Bot Auth | Proving a registered agent is calling | Visa, Cloudflare | No, identifies the agent | Described by Cloudflare; Web Bot Auth is an IETF draft |
| Mastercard Agent Pay | Registered agents, agentic card tokens | Mastercard | Not as its main job | New trust services announced Sep 30, 2026 |
| ACP | In-agent checkout and payment token | Stripe, OpenAI | No | Spec continues; OpenAI scaled back Instant Checkout in Mar 2026 |
| MCP | Tool and data calls | Open standard | No | Used as a route by Poppy and UCP |

## FAQ

### What is Poppy 1.0?

Poppy, formally the Personal Agent Protocol, is an open protocol from Sierra and Meta for how personal AI agents work with businesses. Sierra released version 1.0 on November 13, 2026. A company publishes a file at /.well-known/poppy.json, the agent identifies itself, and the customer decides what access the agent gets.

### Do Shopify merchants need to do anything for Poppy?

No. Sierra says every Shopify store now automatically publishes a Poppy file, and a report from The Next Web says store owners need to do nothing. Shopify's UCP continues to handle carts and checkout.

### Is Poppy a payment protocol?

No. Per the independent spec tracker poppy.md, payments are on the roadmap rather than in the first version. Some live uses involve payments, such as Mercury, where a request must pass the account's approval policy, but Poppy governs access, not money movement.

### How is Poppy different from UCP?

Sierra says UCP covers the shopping itself, such as finding products, filling a cart and checkout, while Poppy covers what comes before: the agent arriving, identifying itself and learning what it is allowed to do. On Shopify the two are used together.

### How is Poppy different from PACT?

Both separate who an agent is from what the customer permits. PACT, from Decagon and Instinct, is built on A2A and OAuth 2.0 and issues a signed delegation token. Poppy uses a published discovery file and OAuth session tokens and can route through a website, APIs or a company's own agent.

### Is Poppy 1.0 final?

Not entirely. Sierra calls it version 1.0, but the specification text still labels itself draft 1.0 and says fixes may not be backward compatible, according to both The Next Web and poppy.md.

## How we evaluated

We started from Sierra's November 13, 2026 release post, confirmed against The Next Web's report and the independent tracker poppy.md, then chose the protocols a business or agent builder would realistically weigh alongside it. We read each protocol's own post or documentation where we could, and flag where we relied on secondary sources. The protocols operate at different layers, so the ranking is by relevance to the question "how does a personal AI agent get let in and what may it do", not a like-for-like feature race. Nothing was tested hands-on.

- Whether the protocol covers agent identity, customer consent, shopping or payment
- How much of the customer's consent and scope control is built in
- Real adoption and how shipped the protocol is today
- Openness of the specification and how much integration work a business must do

## Sources

- [Sierra — Releasing Personal Agent Protocol 1.0 (Nov 13, 2026)](https://sierra.ai/blog/releasing-poppy)
- [Sierra — Poppy announcement and draft (Oct 6 and Oct 9, 2026)](https://sierra.ai/blog/poppy)
- [The Next Web — Sierra releases Poppy 1.0 as Shopify and Meta's Muse sign on](https://thenextweb.com/news/sierra-poppy-1-0-shopify-meta-muse-personal-agents)
- [Unite.AI — Sierra Releases Poppy 1.0 With Shopify and Meta Muse Support](https://www.unite.ai/sierra-releases-poppy-1-0-with-shopify-and-meta-muse-support/)
- [Poppy spec status and comparisons (independent tracker)](https://poppy.md/)
- [Decagon — Introducing PACT (Oct 6, 2026)](https://decagon.ai/blog/introducing-the-personal-agent-consent-trust-protocol-pact)
- [Shopify — Universal Commerce Protocol](https://www.shopify.com/ucp)
- [Cloudflare — Securing agentic commerce with Visa and Mastercard](https://blog.cloudflare.com/secure-agentic-commerce/)
- [Mastercard — new trust and intelligence services (Sep 2026)](https://www.mastercard.com/us/en/news-and-trends/press/2026/september/new-trust-and-intelligence-services.html)
- [Stripe — Developing an open standard for agentic commerce (Sep 29, 2025)](https://stripe.com/blog/developing-an-open-standard-for-agentic-commerce)
